Saturday, August 8, 2015

A Life For A Life: The True Story Of Stefan Kiszko (1998) - FilmReview


Article author: Alwyn Ash
"At the right time, in the right light, everything is extraordinary"


Stefan Kiszko Image



"Maudsley's career began with A Life For A Life. He was the perfect choice for the demanding role."

The murder of 11 year-old Lesley Molseed, born Lesley Anderson, would reach its ultimate conclusion thirty years later, in 2007. She was killed in 1975, by comic book store owner Ronald Castree. The question raised: why did it take so long for her murderer to be brought to justice? Well, for many of those years an innocent man had been jailed for the crime instead. Stefan Ivan Kiszko, a tax clerk, was to become a victim of injustice and gross negligence.

In 1998, his story was told via a brand new televised drama, entitled A Life For A Life, directed by Stephen Whittaker (who had once appeared in the 1968 Doctor Who serial The Web of Fear). Actor Tony Maudsley (Benidorm) starred as Kiszko while American actress Olympia Dukakis was cast in the role of his mother Charlotte.

If I could compare the heartbreak of this case to another, then it would be that of 10 Rillington Place and Timothy Evans, who was hanged for murders committed by serial killer John Christie. Though Kiszko wasn't hanged, the terrible incarceration he endured was so cruel that it is difficult to forgive those whose actions - or lack of - made it possible for the 10-2 verdict in 1976 at Leeds Crown Court. Had certain evidence been produced at his trial, it is clear that Kiszko's innocence wouldn't have been in question. He wasn't guilty, pure and simply.

It didn't help that Kiszko was both mentally and emotionally challenged. During police questioning he wasn't invited to ask for a solicitor, and a request for his mother to be present was refused. While most of us would never admit to a crime we didn't commit, Kiszko believed that if he admitted guilt he would be allowed home. It was a naive attitude but one that fitted in with his way of thinking. Sadly, those who wished to secure a conviction took advantage of his naivety.

Maudsley's career began with A Life For A Life. He was the perfect choice for the demanding role. I dare anyone to watch this film and not feel something for Kiszko. Reviews for the drama have been positive. At the time of broadcast I was living in Northwich, and I remember clearly the emotions that it aroused: I was sick with anger and sadness, not just for Kiszko but for his devoted mother, too! Ultimately, two lives that were destroyed because of a miscarriage of justice.

At time of writing this review, the DVD is difficult to get hold of, having been discontinued for so long. Thankfully I had been fortunate to purchase from a private eBay seller. At last glance someone was selling a copy for £199.99 on Amazon UK!

Lesley Molseed's murder should never be forgotten. A Life For A Life does contain scenes that are upsetting, as we learn much about how she died and graphic descriptions of the crime scene (Rishworth Moor in West Yorkshire) and body. Forensic testing produced results that proved irrefutably that someone other than Kiszko had ejaculated over her clothing, however this crucial evidence was never submitted in court! So, while an innocent man was being railroaded, the girl's true killer remained free.

Kiszko's life in prison was harrowing - in addition to physical assaults from fellow inmates he suffered deteriorating mental health and schizophrenia. He received little sympathy from guards, who believed him to be a child killer. One can only try to imagine how he must have felt. On the outside his mother never gave up fighting on his behalf, even though she came up against indifference from politicians and the legal system in general. Eventually Charlotte Kiszko was put in touch with solicitor Campbell Malone (portrayed by Tony Pritchard). This would be a turning point in the case, which was reopened in 1991. Inconsistencies were established, and previous evidence from teenage girls who had accused Kiszko of exposing himself to them, in 1975, admitted lying in court saying they thought it fun at the time to make up such stories.

He was released in 1992, having spent 16 years behind bars. But this was not to be the end of a sad story: Kiszko died of a heart attack the following year, he was only 41 years-old. His mother Charlotte passed away four months later. They are buried at Rochdale Cemetery, Lancashire.

A Life For A Life is both outstanding drama and a touching portrayal of Kiszko's survival through madness. Considering it was released in 1998, there is no mention of Ronald Castree. Perhaps, if it ever sees a re-release, an accompanying documentary updating the case would be the perfect addition...

Writer Peter Berry won the 1998 RTS (Royal Television Society) award for "Best Screenplay"; while Maudsley won the RTS award for "Network Newcomer - On Screen". Further reading, check out Picture Palace.


Follow @AlwynAsh on Twitter. Image source courtesy of Celtic Films Entertainment/Picture Palace. Article © Alwyn Ash 2015. Quotes (if applicable) used for publicity purposes only. No infringement of copyright is intended.

Tuesday, April 29, 2014

The Secret Of Crickley Hall - TVReview



Article author: Alwyn Ash

"During World War II, Crickley Hall is a home for orphans evacuated from London. In their attic bedroom, the eldest boy, Maurice Stafford walks in and says to a small Jewish boy, Stefan Rosenbaum that 'Mr Cribben wants to see you'. Stefan runs out onto the landing and hides in an airing cupboard..."

Based on the best-selling 2006 novel by James Herbert, "The Secret of Crickley Hall" is one of those haunting tales that brings together child abuse and murder, loss and pain. Set during two parallel time periods (1943 and 2012), we witness first hand the cruelty of Augustus Cribben (played by Douglas Henshall) as he subjugates his charges to his warped sense of morality, aided by his sister Magda Cribben (Sarah Smart), and eldest charge Maurice Stafford (Bill Milner). The past of Crickley Hall is perfectly balanced by the dramas of the present day, as parents Eve and Gabe Caleigh (played by Suranne Jones and Tom Ellis respectively in the 2012 sequences) move from their old family London home to the old house of Crickley after the disappearance of their son Cameron (or "Cam"). The former believes their child to still be alive, refusing to accept any other possibility. This, as it turns out, will be the driving force for her interest in the ghostly goings-on at the Hall.

Throughout the drama, we visit both eras as a story unfolds of cruelty and suspicion, as young Nancy Linnet (Olivia Cooke) accepts a position at Crickley (in 1943) as a tutor for the resident children. The young woman also meets Percy Judd (Iain De Caestecker) and a close friendship develops. In 2012, the Caleigh family (completed by daughters Loren and Cally) live life as best they can, with eldest daughter Loren (Maisie Williams) going to a new school. But something is wrong at the Hall, and pretty soon disturbances convince Eve that their new residence is haunted - and that, somehow, Cameron is connected!

A dramatic retelling is only as good as the cast, and there is exceptional talent to be found in "Crickley", including David Warner as the elderly Percy Judd. Scriptwriter and director Joe Ahearne ("Ultraviolet", "Doctor Who") delivers the best possible piece, masterfully delivering a suspenseful and intriguing play. Originally airing on BBC One between Nov-Dec 2012, the three-part serial may have attracted an average of five million per episode but its elegance remains - this is quite definitely BBC drama at its finest!



The Secret of Crickley Hall © BBC



As the tale progresses we learn that Cribben is both deranged and especially hateful towards a Jewish German orphan boy called Stefan Rosenbaum (Kian Parsiani), taking to his whip far too often and for the most minor of "misdemeanors" - the master of Crickley Hall even keeps a punishment ledger, which we later see reflects the cruelty of his "justice" with crimes such as "Crying", "Refusing to speak" and "Wetting the bed". The pretty Nancy is resolute in exposing Cribben's own immorality, and protect the children in his care from any further harm. They are afraid, and Maurice's subservience acts as a major barrier.

Olivia Cooke fans will, of course, now know her as Emma Decody in the "Bates Motel" television series, and her performance in "Crickley" is a strong one as Nancy, who eventually gains the interest of Parish priest The Reverend Horace (portrayed by Craig Parkinson). But it is undoubtedly Suranne Jones who hits the mark as a grieving mother - a phone call in the last chapter brings Eve the news she had hoped would never come, and her reaction to this is just as haunting as the ghostly drama itself - what else can be expected from an actress whose talents have also touched such roles as Sarah in "Single Father" (2010) and Rachel in "Scott & Bailey"?

There are many surprises, including a visit to an elderly Magda (the part taken by Annie Kelly for these scenes) in the "present day", and the ghostly apparitions of children running up the stairs of Crickley Hall, observed by Eve and her youngest Cally (played by the adorably cute Pixie Davies). And then there is the unseen whipcracking, heard by many including a school bully who takes an immediate dislike to eldest daughter Loren. This adaptation was so good that I just had to go out and visit my local bookstore, purchasing a copy of Herbert's finest example of a ghost story. In the end, it was less Poltergeist-scares and more tragedy-based, with two tales interlinking nicely.

One thing that can be said, the BBC has a way of adapting books for screen, with a sharp eye for period drama especially. You only have to look at its recent track-record: "Little Dorrit" (2008); "Great Expectations" (2011); and this year's success "The Crimson Field" (also starring Suranne Jones), marking the BBC's World War I centenary season of programming. In a 2012 interview, author Herbert had some scepticism regarding the transfer of his novel onto screen, believing its complexity would be impossible to adapt, "For a writer the hardest part is handing your work over to someone else, and letting their vision take over". He seemed genuinely pleased with Ahearne's take on "Crickley Hall".

Thoroughly entertaining, and gripping, with enough emotion to sustain through almost three hours, this is one drama that I recommend to anyone who enjoys a good old-fashioned ghost story. Sadly Herbert passed away in 2013, but he leaves behind an intriguing legacy, one that will be studied and celebrated for many years to come...

Purchase The Secret of Crickley Hall from the Store:
DVD - Book - Running time: 175 minutes

Picture: BBC America


Sunday, April 27, 2014

12 Years A Slave (2013) - FilmReview



Article author: Alwyn Ash

"Days ago I was with my family, in my home. Now you tell me all is lost. 'Tell no one who I really am' if I want to survive. I don't want to survive, I want to live."

Adapted from the memoirs of African American Solomon Northup, director Steve McQueen ("Hunger", "Shame") tells of kidnapping and mistaken identity, culminating in abuse and slavery. Though Solomon was born free in New York, he was abducted in 1841 and sold, forced to work on plantations in Louisiana. For twelve years he suffered cruelty, both physical and emotional, and witnessed the suffering of others just like him, as the law gave no protection - they were simply "property" to their masters. It is ironic that he was a learned man, intelligent and of standing within his own community, and yet during his imprisonment this knowledge was kept concealed from those who abused him. Mistaken for another man, he worked hard, endured pain and humiliation, but remained focused on the day when he would be free again, and return home to his family...

It has to be said that all the cast play their parts not just well but perfectly balanced and expertly embraced, credit going to everyone involved in this fine production. Actor Chiwetel Ejiofor gives the most warming performance as Solomon, with actress Lupita Nyong'o tugging at the heart strings portraying the role of Patsey, a fellow slave at one of the plantations where Solomon eventually ends up. It appears director McQueen cannot put a foot wrong with his selection of films; he has won awards, and been nominated so many times for his achievements that it is an honour to watch a master at his craft, experiencing the finest of cinema.

If you haven't already read the cast list then there are some nice surprises. First up is English actor Benedict Cumberbatch ("Sherlock", "Star Trek: Into Darkness") as kind plantation owner William Ford, who is so impressed by the slave's idea of transporting logs across a swamp that he gives Northup a violin as a gift. Of course, even here, tensions are high as Northup is targeted by Over-seer John Tibeats, who clearly despises him. After a short altercation the slave is almost lynched, and he is sold to new owner Edwin Epps (Michael Fassbender). This is where the story takes a far more sinister turn...



12 Years A Slave



At this point the plot really steps up as God-loving Epps and his wife Mary (powerfully played by Sarah Paulson) demonstrate such cruelty towards their "property", the former inflicting beatings for failure to reach expected cotton production targets: 200 pounds daily. Patsey's hard work in collecting 500-plus is applauded by her owner, who not just rapes her regularly but develops an obsession with the young slave. This eventually leads to persecution from Mary, who both humiliates and physically attacks her. McQueen certainly does nothing to shy away from the brutalities of slavery, with scenes of lashings that will likely upset. It could be argued that the director wished simply to produce an accurate portrayal of life during the early to mid-1800s for the average slave, and he manages it with stark honesty.

Another welcome casting comes in the form of Brad Pitt (also producer in this feature), whose performance as gentle laborer Samuel Bass works well in contrast to the hard and unforgiving Epps. Northup and the newcomer strike a close bond while building a gazebo, and the latter learns of the slave's true story - how he was kidnapped and sold into slavery. The scenes between Ejiofor and Pitt are touching and well-written, as are those between Ejiofor and Nyong'o; you can appreciate why Nyong'o won the "Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress", her acting certainly brought a tear to this reviewer's eye!

"12 Years A Slave" is visually breathtaking and stunningly-shot, rich in colour and depth, making everything of John Ridley's screenplay. The time period is splendidly reproduced. After an initial meeting, McQueen and Ridley were keen to develop a feature that would focus on slavery in America. It was thanks to McQueen's wife that Solomon Northup's 1853 memoir came to light. The director commented in an interview (NPR), "I read this book, and I was totally stunned. It was like a bolt coming out of the sky; at the same time I was pretty upset with myself that I didn't know this book." I can fully understand the passion felt for this feature, having not been so emotionally affected by a single movie since Steven Spielberg's 1993 historical drama "Schindler's List". You cannot help but feel empathy for the slaves, and Northup's plight, rage toward Epps and his jealous wife, and an overall sense of appreciation for what those in slavery had to face during those harsh times.

Just like Spielberg's masterpiece, McQueen delivers a painful but insightful biopic, thought-provoking in ways I had not expected. It is even more poignant when you consider that racism is still existent in the modern world, and not just a warped attitude from a bygone era. Such mindsets are heartbreaking, and with "12 Years A slave" we get to see racial cruelty and tragedy in all their forms. Finally, no film is ever complete without its music score, and composer Hans Zimmer ("Crimson Tide", "Inception") excels at his art, achieving the right mixture to compliment the sentimental tides that each scene produces. I highly recommend this deeply powerful and moving drama.

Purchase 12 Years A Slave from the Store:
DVD / Blu-ray - Running time: 134 minutes

Picture: 12 Years: Official website


Tuesday, July 9, 2013

The Impossible (2012) - FilmReview

Article author: Alwyn Ash


When a family is torn apart, courage must take over...

I don't often allow myself to watch highly emotionally-charged true-life movies, simply because I find such a thing impossible, being a very sensitive and emotional person myself. And so opening up to these kind of experiences is both physically and, yes, emotionally tiring. However, when I heard of The Impossible - and knowing that the feature starred Naomi Watts - I just had to see what the fuss was all about. I certainly had no idea that the film focused on the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami until I read the synopsis. What I discovered was a powerful and captivating tale chronicling disaster, bravery and humanity at its finest.

Based on Spanish physician María Belón and her family's experiences during and following the tragic events, Watts is cast as "English" physician Maria Bennet (temporary retired from practice), who travels with her husband Henry (Ewan McGregor) and three children Lucas (Tom Holland), Tomas (Samuel Joslin), and Simon (Oakley Pendergrast) to Khao Lak, Thailand, for the Christmas holidays. The fun isn't to last long. This beautiful paradise becomes the scene of mayhem when a flood hits, indiscriminately taking lives and destroying homes. The horrifying event is well realised, with effects that easily call up memories of those news broadcasts we had watched with deep sympathy and sadness for both the Indian Ocean and similar tsunami victims. Not one scene is taken for granted, or wasted.








In the wake of this mass destruction, the film focuses on both Maria and her eldest son Lucas, who are both swept away by the flood but manage to find one another; the former severely injured. It has to be said that both actors do a wonderful job, and it is easy to feel for them - separated from Henry and the other two children, whose fate remains a mystery at this time, mother and son at least have each other. In a lovely scene, they are soon joined by a toddler named Daniel, who is found alone and in wreckage.

There had been criticism regarding the movie's "whitewashing", casting "white" actors to make ethnic characters "more appealing to the white", with the main issue being that a white Western family gets caught up in a tsunami instead of a true reflection of the Spanish family whose experiences this feature is based on. I disagree, however. There is no sign that Spanish director Juan Antonio Bayona or writer Sergio G. Sánchez are purposefully engaging in such an act - the casting of Watts and McGregor is a wise one as they are clearly capable of delivering a performance that is needed for such demanding roles (how would Penélope Cruz have fared as María Belón, I wonder?). Even the young cast is exceptional, not once failing to embrace the script with true purpose. "Lo Imposible" is a Spanish production and, thankfully, overall response for the film has been positive.

The Impossible solidly hammers home the true nature of such a disaster, using authentic locations and focusing solely on the Human need for hope, bravery and compassion. Though their homes and lives have been wrecked, the Thai people work tirelessly in a bid to help tsunami victims (both local and tourists). They are the true heroes in this magnificent true-life tale that shines throughout...

Even when it is revealed that Maria, Lucas and Henry have survived the initial flood, it is clear that Maria isn't out of the woods yet - her injuries are extensive and surgery is required. Henry, too, is in search of his family, not knowing whether they are alive or dead. And there is plenty to admire about this movie, especially when Lucas leaves his mother's bedside to help others in the hospital, even reuniting a father and son in one touching scene. In another, Henry encounters a group of people - one of them, a German man named Karl Schweber (Sönke Möhring) permits the Scottish husband to use his cellphone, which leads to a rather emotional call home.

Whatever your own thoughts on the "whitewash", there is no denying that this feature is a total assault on the senses, an honest account of tragedy, loss and survival regardless of race, a heartbreaking walk through events when a tsunami injects terror into a delicate community. This is indeed one movie with fine performances from all involved, and a respectful account of the horrific tsunami that occurred on Sunday 26th December 2004, killing over 230,000 people. It is a firm reminder that we are fragile in nature, and that nothing is ever certain.



Thursday, May 23, 2013

Wentworth: Episode 2 "Fly Me Away" - TVReview

Article author: Alwyn Ash


Taking a look at the most eagerly-awaited re-imagining.

Re-introducing already established characters can be a very difficult and risky process, especially when these much-loved people are connected with one of the greatest cult television shows in Australia, and indeed the UK. Without going into further background information (see previous review "No Place Like Home") the second episode of Wentworth kicks off in style. However, while the debut episode focused on Bea Smith (played by Danielle Cormack) being brought in on remand, and spent the three quarters of an hour introducing the various men and women on both sides of the bars, the second visit to Wentworth gave us a beautiful tale of Doreen Anderson, portrayed so wonderfully by Shareena Clanton. There is also a staff re-shuffle as Prisoner Advocate Erica Davidson (Leeanna Walsman) sets her sights on greater things...

Having watched this episode with interest, I cannot help but take back some of my words in my first review: "I do wonder why Cormack was cast as Bea when she would have been so perfect as Karen Travers, jailed for the murder of her husband (as in the 1979 production); McQuade could have then been cast as Bea", as I now feel strongly that this reimagined look at Bea's incarceration is, in fact, in perfect and safe hands with Cormack in the role.

It is also exciting to see actor Robbie Magasiva tackling his part of Officer Will Jackson with such emotion as he resorts to blackmail in a bid to manipulate Doreen (Clanton). Of course, Will is not a bad man, but recent events have tipped him over the edge - he is a husband on a mission, his actions quite clearly inviting dangerous consequences.



Doreen Anderson (Shareena Clanton) and Bea Smith
(Danielle Cormack) - Wentworth





And so, second chapter in and Wentworth is delivering fine drama with equally fine casting and direction. Tensions between Franky Doyle (Nicole da Silva) and Jacs Holt (Kris McQuade) are simmering after the riot, though we know it cannot be too long before something happens between them again. But for now it is Bea who finds herself a target as she is suspected of committing one of the worst crimes imaginable. This, and the blackmail, leads Doreen into making a heartbreaking decision regarding her daughter Kaiya (Tanika Fry is simply adorable, isn't she?), although we later discover something that makes the separation from a child even more painful - the revelation that... *Spoilers not available*

Still, writer Pete McTighe and director Kevin Carlin manage to deliver enough sentiment to a scene that will see Doreen pick up and cuddle a teddy bear (actress Colette Mann, who played the character of Doreen in the original Prisoner, would be proud!)

Having had an opportunity to first compare Wentworth to its predeccesor in my earlier review "No Place Like Home", and now able to accept Lara Radulovich and David Hannam's vision on its own merits, I am absolutely satisfied with current developments and direction - the series has yet to take a step wrong, and the casting is 100% perfection; strong characters played by strong and versatile actors.

For this review special mention should be given to Georgia Flood as Debbie Smith, who not only got to see her father almost die but now has to experience the emotions of her mother Bea behind bars. Who would have thought that a scene between two characters, one at each end of a phone, would be calling for tears of relief and joy? This is the true heart of Wentworth, those tender and touching moments.

And so the third episode is around the corner, and there are many playing cards on the table. Just how will Erica (Walsman) adjust to new responsibilities? And can Will (Magasiva) ever come to terms with his own predicament? Not to mention the feud between Franky (Nicole da Silva) and Jacs (McQuade); we know that if she continues to get caught up in the middle of their power games, Bea must learn to fight back, as she has already demonstrated she is quite capable of doing during her initial confrontation with Jacs in the first episode.



Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Wentworth: Episode 1 "No Place Like Home" - TVReview

Article author: Alwyn Ash


Taking a look at the most eagerly-awaited re-imagining.

Prior to the broadcast of the debut episode of Wentworth, there had been much discussion from fans of popular cult television Australian drama Prisoner (known as Prisoner: Cell Block H in the UK and US, and Caged Women in Canada) whether a new treatment would serve to be as popular...

Airing between 1979-86 (692 episodes) on Network Ten, Prisoner focused on the lives of women behind bars, tackling both prison adjustment and personal conflict. It had given us strong female characters played by equally inspirational women such as Bea Smith (Val Lehman), Joan Ferguson (Maggie Kirkpatrick), Erica Davidson (Patsy King), Rita Connors (Glenda Linscott), and Ann Reynolds (Gerda Nicolson).

Now, more than twenty years after the original show ended, welcome once more to Wentworth Detention Centre. Except, this time, some of those familiar names have returned, albeit with difference faces and personalities...

So is Wentworth (a brand new drama commissioned by Foxtel) a remake, sequel or prequel? Honestly, it is none of the latter; more of a re-imagining along the same rout as Ronald D. Moore's Battlestar Galactica took with its revival. Though characters such as Bea, Lizzie Birdsworth and Frankie Doyle are present, it is clear that any connection with the original series is very loose indeed. For example, Doreen Anderson is portrayed here by Shareena Clanton, and Lizzie is so far from her original counterpart that she might as well be a different person entirely.



Bea Smith (Danielle Cormack), Franky Doyle (Nicole da Silva),
and Jacs Holt (Kris McQuade) - Wentworth





A rip-off then, and something that fans of Prisoner should distance themselves from, as some people seem to have done long before its initial airing? In all fairness, Wentworth is a familiar tread through the world of prison life, but there is no doubt that this update has something of its own - the characters, though familiar by name if not looks, have the same potential as their originals, the scripts are tight and engaging, and the casting is first rate. That said, I do wonder why Cormack was cast as Bea when she would have been so perfect as Karen Travers, jailed for the murder of her husband (as in the 1979 production); McQuade could have then been cast as Bea; Nicole da Silva as Franky is an excellent choice however.

And perhaps Wentworth would have served better as a sequel to the original rather than any other type, with fresh characters altogether? Regardless, for this fan, there is definitely room for both. I am still happy.

If the writing and direction remain constant throughout its run, there should be no reason why this new concept from Lara Radulovich and David Hannam (based on Reg Watson's original vision) shouldn't be a long-term success. It does have much to live up to compared with Prisoner, Bad Girls (UK drama produced by Shed Productions), and even Within These Walls (UK drama produced by London Weekend Television) - all television dramas focusing on a women's prison.

As for the debut episode itself we are introduced to housewife and hairdresser Bea Smith (Cormack), who arrives at Wentworth Detention Centre on remand for the attempted murder of her husband. This is her first time in prison and there is much to adjust to, as she quickly discovers. A power struggle between fellow inmates Franky Doyle (Nicole da Silva) and Jacs Holt (Kris McQuade) is reaching boiling point and it isn't long before something occurs - with horrifying results...

Shareena Clanton will undoubtedly be the other star as we see her character's story develop. By "Episode 2: Fly Me Away" we will learn of Doreen Anderson's personal heartbreak. And Leeanna Walsman, cast as Prisoner Advocate Erica Davidson, is another face to watch, as there are changes afoot at Wentworth... As for Danielle Cormack and Nicole da Silva - excellent performances ladies!



Tuesday, April 9, 2013

In The Flesh: Episode 3 - TVReview

Article author: Alwyn Ash


"There is no denying that In The Flesh is the kind of television drama needed."

Set in the fictional English village of Roarton, the final part was all about departure (as Amy Dyer - portrayed by Emily Bevan - said an emotional farewell), revenge (Bill Macey's execution at the hands of Ken Burton), and a family reunited (this has always been the heart of the tale). In other ways, Part Three felt rushed...

It was always going to be interesting, seeing just how this tale of Partially Deceased Syndrome (PDS) sufferers being returned to the community would work out, and on the whole writer Dominic Mitchell has worked a miracle; In The Flesh is perfect original entertainment, offering more than just a zombie rising and scenes of gore as they eat their way through the residents of Roarton. Instead, the zombies are not traditional zombies at all but victims of PDS, which caused them to rise from their graves and, yes, eat the residents of Roarton. But we see this purely as flashbacks.

The tale handed to us as a slice of BBC Three entertainment focuses on rehabilitation as "Rotters" are treated, before being permitted to see their friends and families. Reintegration. This, in itself, is dangerous - members of the HVF (Human Volunteer Force) are on the look out for any "Rotter" and will likely shoot to kill, which is precisely what happened to Ken's wife in one disturbing consequence.




Ricky Tomlinson as Ken Burton





Without going into too much past detail (see reviews for In The Flesh), it was clear from day one that 18-year-old Kieren Walker's relationship with his parents and sister Jem was always going to be resolved in a positive way - it would be heartbreaking not to; Jemima Walker (played by the talented Harriet Cains) had shown hostility toward her brother from the moment he first returned and yet... she was far from being a cold-hearted participator of the HVF, nor did she harbour the same feelings of disgust that someone like HVF leader Bill displayed - this was apparent many times, including her reaction to the killing of Ken Burton's PDS suffering wife at the conclusion of the opening episode. It is therefore heartfelt, during a flashback, that we discover Jem's reluctance to destroy her own brother during a moment in his untreated state, following the rising.

Kieren's parents, too (portrayed by Marie Critchley and Steve Cooper) had to finally face the reality of their new life - the latter, Steve (who had discovered his son's body following the suicide that would eventually lead to Kieren's PDS condition), had suppressed so much emotion that he was finally able to let rip. This was encouraged by Kieren, as father and son were finally able to engage in a way not seen since Kieren's rising. Add to that the beautiful scene between mother and son, as Sue exchanges such a perfect moment of comfort in the cave where Kieren had originally died, "This time, you live, you don’t leave, you stay" in response to her son's loss...

...and this is where the story regained its cruel footing - the murder of PDS sufferer Rick Macey (David Walmsley), at the hands of his own father! As with Ken Burton's wife, this was a tragic set of events as Bill's twisted sense of morality finally urged him to take action and destroy the doppelganger that had dared to live in his home, taking the place of his deceased son. This, of course, was followed by the equally shock shooting of Bill, as Ken (whose presence in Part Two had been sadly lacking) finally sought the justice he felt was deserved. Brutal, and perhaps a little empty with its execution (pun intended); perhaps a scene depicting Ken's arrest would have balanced out the story, demonstrating that a "Rotter" is not protected by law - hence Bill's heartless actions receiving no legal comeuppance...

Kieren's old hunting partner Amy didn't have too much to sink her teeth in to with the final episode, instead choosing to leave Roarton. However, once more this scene was touched with genuine passion as both Bevan and Luke Newberry said their farewells. Seeing Luke confronting his own demons, facing his nightmares head on by visiting the parents of one of his victims also demonstrated the power of the script writing.

Perhaps three parts were never quite enough, as there was so much more that should have been developed further. However, that said, there is no denying that In The Flesh is the kind of television drama needed. Indeed, writer Mitchell must be congratulated on his vision - a debut in more ways than one...

Thank goodness for ‘Northern Voices’, the BBC Writersroom scheme that gave us, the viewers, an opportunity to enjoy the skills of a very talented man. And, equally, a very talented team that brought his world to life.



Tuesday, March 26, 2013

In The Flesh: Episode 2 - TVReview

Article author: Alwyn Ash


Second part manages to be more than just a zombie outing - even the Rotters in the woods show their Human quality...

The debut of new BBC Three drama In The Flesh had Kieren Walker (Luke Newberry) returning home after undergoing rehabilitation, medicated and his true nature disguised, only to find a hostile and suspicious community preparing for the arrival of any PDS (Partially Deceased Syndrome) sufferers who dare to return to the remote Northern village of Roarton. A shock ending saw the heartless killing of Ken Burton's wife, Maggie, who had, until treated and medicated, been a "Rotter", one of the walking dead. As Bill Macy had put it, "I seem to recall, Ken, last time I saw yer wife, she were in a casket." Actor Ricky Tomlinson portrayed the role excellently, as a man forced to watch his wife die, for a second time.

It is therefore ironic that Bill (played by Steve Evets), leader of the Human Volunteer Force vigilante group, is forced to face his own demons in the form of his soldier son, Rick Macy (David Walmsley), who was believed to be dead until recently. Quite clearly this is a man who hates "Rotters" with every fiber of his being and yet... acknowledging the truth about his own grown-up child is going to be painful and soul searching; and how hypocritical that he leaves neighbour Ken without a wife but choices to ignore the reality of his own situation. He is not alone either - Rick is also in denial, it seems.



Emily Bevan in the flesh




There is also a question to be asked concerning the close relationship between Kieren and Rick; are they simply friends, or is there more to it? This is where In The Flesh works extremely well, focusing less on the traditional zombie elements and instead piecing together the lives of the residents. There is love, hate, suspicion, guilt and so much more where the series demonstrates its true power. For example, though Jem Walker (Harriet Cains) is a member of the HVF, her loyalty to her family is obvious, even if she does make it known that her actions were not born out of any concern for her brother.

And when Kieren finally steps through the doors of the local British Legion, there is far less hostility than expected; instead these are people who simply feel uncomfortable around a reanimated friend or neighbour, not eager zombie killers who might be seen in more traditional tales (In The Flesh may have its footing in the wake of American filmmaker George A. Romero's movies but its own focus reflects an intriguing side not touched upon before in this way: what happens if a zombie can be treated?) - this is a close community and their reaction to events not so predictable.

Emily Bevan wonderfully portrays Kieren's old "Rotter" hunting partner, Amy Dyer, as the two are reunited while Kieren visits his own grave (it becomes clear that his wishes to be cremated were ignored by his parents). Amy remembers him, and soon a new uneasy friendship is formed. They are on opposite ends of emotion, as it becomes apparent that Amy feels no regret whatsoever for her actions during an untreated state, "Back then, we were in survival mode, out of our minds".

We are also treated to a touching scene between Kieren and Amy as the two share something about their deaths; Amy had died of Leukemia, Kieren sucide. Amy undoubtedly brings both humour and warmth with her vivacious personality, and is easily the perfect foil to Kieren - whereas he is full of guilt, she has been given a second chance at life and will damn well make the most of it! Her decision to go "au naturale" by rejecting both makeup and contact lenses is a perfect example of Amy's nonconformity, even if the rules were set in place to both keep her safe and the public from panicking.

On a last note, the sighting of a rabid Rotter in the woods leads to one of the most astonishing moments in television history - a grown male zombie demonstrating primitive and yet clear paternal instincts toward a zombie female child, both untreated and still in a feral state of being. Though Bill urges his son to shoot these two Rotters, it is Kieren who steps up, persuading both his friend and the others in the group to capture the Rotters instead. This is where we realise just how possible it was to treat the infected in the first place, for they never truly lost "themselves"...

If the 'rising' is a metamorphosis, are the "Rotters" a moth or butterfly? In Amy's case, I would say the latter. And if "Zombie theology" suggests that the soul is separated from the body at the point of death prior to it being reanimated, then what of Dominic Mitchell's creations? They have souls, they remember. That is where In The Flesh sets new ground; to die is to be reborn, albeit in an unprecedented new world.



Monday, March 18, 2013

In The Flesh: Episode 1 - TVReview

Article author: Alwyn Ash


"In The Flesh is a human story, looking at tragedy, guilt, acceptance, and both justice and injustice..."

Imagine, a world of zombies, the kind of soulless creatures that rise from their graves to devour human flesh, aimlessly stalking the neighborhood, a ravage hunger and a violent nature for killing. There would be a fight for survival, as those who lived fought the dead, destroying these ghouls in the most traditional of methods - the head! But what if... the state of a zombie could be conditioned with medication, and the deceased returned to society?

In Dominic Mitchell's well-crafted drama for BBC3 we are introduced to a world proceeding a zombie apocalypse; those who were once monsters undergo treatment and rehabilitation, before being released back into the community, where they are returned to families and friends. How will people respond? The unease of knowing what the zombie - now officially recognised as a sufferer of PDS (Partially Deceased Syndrome) - has done in the time of its untreated state would always sit in the back of anyone's mind.

Eighteen-year-old Kieren Walker (played by Luke Newberry) is one such person. We are introduced to him at a Partially Deceased Treatment Centre in Norfolk. This is the place where he has been prepared for his new life in the remote Northern village of of Roarton, where he lived before his death. Adjustment is key, a chance to exist again. That is, unless the Human Volunteer Force (HVF), a vigilante group, has other ideas...



Sisterly love, Cains as Jem





His sister Jem Walker (excellently portrayed by Harriet Cains), who has been a member of the HVF since the rising, clearly has mixed feelings toward her brother; however it is pleasing to see that her loyalty to the family outweighed any existing apprehensions.

Three-part drama In The Flesh is a human tale, looking at tragedy, guilt, acceptance, and both justice and injustice; a cleansing, the need for some to hunt down and destroy those who had died only to rise again (those who had murdered family, friends and neighbours in the process), and the existence of informers within the village, had my mind visualising the persecution of the Jewish community during the Second World War under German occupation; how people would be dragged out of their hiding places into the street, and shot in front of neighbours and loved ones, or forced to leave due to the constant fear of being caught, always looking over your shoulder, through gaps in curtains, questioning who to trust... It is an uneasy reminder that, given extraordinary circumstances, the unthinkable is possible.

Even the very idea of a PDS sufferer being released back into their old lives, once more interacting with friends and family, medication keeping their condition at bay, reminded this reviewer of someone recently out of a psychiatric hospital, now medicated but memories of their previous imbalanced actions still present in people's minds. Stigma and discrimination, an uneasy sense of suspicion and fear, the doubt of whether this person might just revert back to how they used to be, especially if they had once been violent and dangerous, as these "Rotters" clearly were... The world that Dominic Mitchell has visualised is more than just a story of survival in a zombie apocalypse - In The Flesh portrays the walking dead as victims that must face anger, suspicion, and guilt.

The cast is nicely gathered, with fine performances by Marie Critchley and Steve Cooper (as Kieran's parents Sue and Steve), Ricky Tomlinson (as Ken Burton), Steve Evets (playing HVF leader Bill Macy), and Kenneth Cranham (as Vicar Oddie - he's all about forgiveness, this one!)

Jonny Campbell directs superbly, clearly loving Mitchell's script as he takes every scene, shining such visual depth and haunting bite that, every step of the way, we are drawn into the drama with a sense of our very own apprehension - we want everything to work out, for the past to be forgiven, and these sufferers to be accepted; but we fear the possible, know that any one of these medicated "Rotters" could be held accountable for their "crimes". Or that, without treatment, they are nothing more than mindless killers...